This morning I woke up to the terrible (although not completely unexpected) news that Christopher Hitchens had died. The rational community has, of course, lost one of its most erudite and interesting members. But it seems that Christopher had one last trick up his sleeve.
As with most breaking news these days, I found out about his death from Twitter. I checked my Twitter feed as I got up at about 6am. A few people that I follow were already awake and discussing it. As a mark of respect, many of those tweets were tagged with the name of Hitchens’ best known book “God Is Not Great“. And then more and more people started to do that. And before too long, the hashtag #GodIsNotGreat was listed as one of Twitter’s worldwide trending topics. At which point it started to go a bit weird.
All around the world religious people who knew nothing at all about Christopher Hitchens, his books or his death were looking at Twitter and seeing the tag #GodIsNotGreat. And that annoyed many of them immensely. So they started tweeting on the subject. Their tweets seemed to largely fall into three categories.
1/ What is this? And why is it trending?
2/ Attempts to inject their own beliefs into the stream – “God isn’t just great – he’s the GREATEST!!” (from someone called foolishdenise – you couldn’t make this up)
3/ Threats to kill whoever had started the hashtag (all very Christian) [UPDATE: Replaced a tweet with a rather NSFW background with another expressing the same sentiment]
Of course, all of these new tweets all included the hashtag. So that just helped ensure that the hashtag became even more popular. Hitchens fans replied, pointing out why the hashtag was trending (and inviting them to read the book) and the hashtag was tweeted and retweeted and commented on and argued over more than pretty much any other hashtag I’ve followed all year. For most of the morning the Tweetdeck column I set up to follow the tag was moving too fast for me to follow it.
At some point in the morning, the hashtag disappeared from the list of trending topics. Some people claimed that Twitter had removed it deliberately in response to the Christian death threats. But it seems slightly ironic for Hitchens fans to claim something like that without any firm evidence. I suspect that it’s more likely that once a hashtag reaches a plateau of activity then Twitter’s algorithm ignores it – otherwise the top trend would always be Justin Bieber (as two people pointed out to me). Apparently it’s still trending in Canada. But I’m not sure what that proves about anything.
One tweet in particular from luketadams summed things up for me.
Hitchens dies. His book
#GodisNotGreat trends. Religious people threaten violence. The point of his book is proven. Hitchens for the win.
It’s tempting to imagine Hitchens looking down on the storm that his death has caused and laughing. But that would go against everything that he believed in.
So don’t do that. Instead, reread his articles, buy his books, watch videos of him demolishing his opponents in debate. And remember the great mind that we have lost.
But did you hear the guilty sigh of relief from the apologists, when they understood that they would never have to face him again in debate?
I’ve never seen this blog before. Someone linked this post in a thread. Thanks for writing this, Dave. It was excellent, and a nice bit of fun amongst the despair of losing Hitch.
Greetings! Another blog post led me here, and I thank you muchly for posting this. I tweeted and contributed to the mayhem, but it’s no longer trending in Canada.
It was a fitting tribute to his memory.
I’m proposing a new law–that whoever fantasizes first about their opponent burning in Hell loses the argument!
You won’t do well in my new FantasizeAboutYourOpponentBurningInHellFirst-lympics.
thank you so much for this – hitch would have loved it!
Thank you for this post. I, too, was led here by another blog (Pharyngula). I’d like to chime in and agree that this was a nice moment of levity in the general sadness off Hitch’s death.
If even one theist got wind of the hashtag and found themselves reading some of Hitchens’ writing, then I’d put that in the “Win” column.
It really sucks that he’s gone. He’d have had a good laugh about this.
I meant, of course, “the general sadness of Hitch’s death.”
Great article. Hitch’s going was always going to cause a day when his views were going to be more widely seen. And that means seen by more people who wouldn’t otherwise have known. His real target audience. Believers.
Let’s hope reason will reach a few million more in one big hit.
As an aside. Today was also the day when David Cameron chose to state that one of the greatest achievements of the UK, The King James Bible, had its anniversary year and to state he’s a christian on Twitter. If that doesn’t alienate him from a lot of atheists in one hit, I don’t know what will.
I’m glad I read this post before I read others suggesting that Twitter was censoring #GodIsNotGreat (or #JustinBieber),
Thanks!
I agree that Hitch would’ve found it all funny.
We have lost a mentor, adviser, a friend, a voice. He will be missed greatly.
The test of science: a condition that can disprove a theory.
The test of religion: behavior towards unbelievers.
Use your brain and don’t ape Hitchens who is already a lost case…Remember Dave, you have only one life to live on this planet earth….Goodluck my friend!
Exactly. We do have only one life to lead. And that’s why we should live it to the full and not get caught up in the restrictions of religion.